Shields Up: Guarding Your Estate Against Fraud and Undue Influence

Estate planning is a crucial element of financial management, dealing with the lawful distribution of an individual's property post their demise. The instrument of this transmission, often a will or trust, encapsulates donative transfers, essentially meaning the gifts made through these legal documents.

California Probate Law, particularly Section 21380, revolves around the topic of donative transfers, which can often be a complex and misunderstood area of estate planning law. This blog aims to simplify and demystify the intricacies of this particular aspect of California law.

Decoding Probate Code §21380 and Donative Transfers

A 'donative transfer' is a gift made via estate planning documents such as a will or a trust. It entails the allocation of one's assets to another. While donative transfers can be executed through various documents, they typically involve either a will or trust.

Section 21380 of California Probate Law scrutinizes donative transfers made to specific individuals. This section is essentially about safeguarding individuals when they are transferring their assets through their will or trust. The law presumes that there may be a possibility of fraud or undue influence, particularly when the following individuals are involved:

1. The individual who drafted the document.

2. Any person who transcribed the instructions into the document, especially if they were entrusted with looking out for the grantor's interests.

3. A caregiver, specifically for dependent adults, who were providing care at or around the time the document was signed, or within three months before or after its execution.

4. A live-in caregiver, who began cohabitating or married the grantor around the time the document was signed or within three months after they ceased providing care, but only if the document was signed or the gift was made less than six months after they started living together or got married.

5. Anyone closely related (up to a first cousin) to the drafter, transcriber, or the caregiver.

6. An individual residing with or employed by the drafter, transcriber, or caregiver.

7. A business partner, investor, or employee of a law firm where the drafter or transcriber of the document is an owner.

Essentially, red flags may arise on gifts to the lawyer, caregiver, their family, staff, or anyone they cohabit with.

The Purpose of Probate Code §21380

Section 21380 was designed to protect potentially vulnerable people from being unduly influenced during the estate planning process. 'Undue influence' is the exertion of power to persuade a person to make a decision that may not be in their best interests.

To circumnavigate potential issues of undue influence, it's advisable to have estate planning documents drafted by an independent attorney who won't benefit from the estate. Privacy in estate planning is crucial to preventing undue influence, and, whenever possible, there should be a witness present during the signing of important documents.

Understanding Fraud within the Context of Probate Law

Fraud is generally understood to be a deliberate act of deception for unfair gain. In the context of probate law, there are two main types: fraud in the execution and fraud in the inducement. The former involves tricking someone into signing a document without understanding its implications, while the latter involves misleading a person about the contents of a document they know they are signing.

Typically, fraud involves several elements: a false representation, the knowledge of its falsehood, an intention to deceive, reliance on false information, and harm as a result.

Rebutting the Presumption of Undue Influence or Fraud

If a donative transfer is presumed to be a product of fraud or undue influence, the burden of proof falls on the parties involved to provide strong evidence to the contrary. If the presumed beneficiary fails to convincingly prove the absence of undue influence or fraud, they could face legal consequences, including bearing the costs of the proceedings and forfeiture of the gift.

Key Takeaway

The crucial message here is the importance of meticulous estate planning. It's essential to seek independent legal advice, maintain privacy in planning, and ensure the presence of impartial witnesses during the signing of documents. This can greatly minimize the risks of fraud or undue influence and ensure the integrity of one's estate planning process.

It is always advisable to engage with professionals who can provide sound advice in the field of estate planning, taxes, real estate, and finances, and provide guidance through complex legal terrain like California Probate Law, Section 21380.

BETHEL LAW CORPORATION
ESTATE PLANNING | ELDER LAW | BUSINESS PLANNING

CLICK HERE OR CALL US AT 909-307-6282 TO SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION.

Featured