In California, the role of a trustee is crucial for managing a trust’s assets, distributing funds, and ensuring the trust’s terms are executed accurately. But what happens when there’s no trustee to manage the trust? Although rare, trustee vacancies can lead to significant legal challenges. This article explores what causes trustee vacancies, the legal protocols for filling them, and practical steps to avoid potential issues in your own estate planning.

Why a Trustee is Essential for Your Trust

For a trust to be legally valid, it must have an active trustee. Under California law, a trust without a trustee cannot function. The trustee’s responsibilities extend beyond title; they are vital for overseeing asset management, fund distribution, and other essential functions. A trustee vacancy compromises the trust's ability to operate effectively, potentially causing delays, disputes, and even litigation among beneficiaries.

Common Causes for Trustee Vacancies

Trustee vacancies typically occur due to resignation, death, incapacity, or removal. Here’s a closer look at those scenarios:

Resignation: A trustee may step down if they’re no longer able or willing to serve. However, until a new trustee is appointed, the resigning trustee remains responsible for actions taken during the transition.

Death or Incapacity: A trustee’s passing or incapacity can create an immediate vacancy, affecting the trust’s operations until a replacement is appointed.

Removal: In cases where the trustee fails to fulfill their duties, they may be removed, either by court order or, in some cases, per the trust’s terms. The trustee remains accountable until a new one is appointed.

Learn more: Everything You Need to Know on Trustee Removal, Resignation & Death

Filling a Trustee Vacancy: California’s Probate Code

California’s Probate Code Section 15660 provides a structured method for filling a trustee vacancy. This process ensures continuity in trust administration while safeguarding beneficiary interests. Here are the three main steps:

Follow the Trust’s Instructions: The first step is to check the trust document. If it specifies a procedure for appointing a new trustee or names a successor, those directions take precedence.

Beneficiary Agreement: In the absence of instructions, the trust’s adult beneficiaries can select a successor by mutual agreement. This successor could be a financial advisor, family member, or another trusted individual.

Court Appointment: If neither of the above methods resolves the vacancy, any interested party may petition the court to appoint a trustee. The court considers nominees from beneficiaries aged 14 or older and ultimately selects a qualified individual.

An “interested party” typically includes family members, guardians, conservators, or professionals related to the case, like attorneys or financial advisors.

Creating Built-in Safety Nets in Your Trust

At Bethel Law, we incorporate specific language in trust documents to handle trustee vacancies. Here’s a brief outline of the procedure we follow if all designated trustees cannot serve:

Recommendation by the Current Trustee: If a trustee plans to retire, they may nominate a replacement, provided they are not being removed.

Beneficiary Agreement: If the current trustee is unavailable to recommend a successor, all adult beneficiaries vote on a new trustee. In some cases, voting may be limited to income beneficiaries.

Court Appointment: If the beneficiaries cannot reach a consensus, the court will appoint a new trustee.

We generally recommend trustees have expertise in finance, real estate, or tax matters to ensure efficient trust management, though the only legal requirement is they be at least 18 years old.

Learn more: Do Trustees Get Paid? What You Need to Know About Trustee Compensation

The Importance of Selecting a Qualified Trustee

While the Probate Code provides a fallback, proactive planning can help avoid these issues. Selecting a reliable trustee or appointing a professional trustee ensures minimal court involvement and reduces the likelihood of conflicts among beneficiaries. A strong trustee setup preserves the integrity of your estate plan and maintains harmony within your family.

Conclusion

A trust’s effectiveness hinges on its trustee. Without a designated trustee, the trust cannot operate, leaving assets and beneficiaries vulnerable. To avoid this, review your trust periodically, confirm your trustee appointments, and establish a plan for unexpected vacancies.

Learn more: California Trust Beneficiary Notice Requirements: Trustee Duty & CA 16061.7

BETHEL LAW CORPORATION
ESTATE PLANNING | ELDER LAW | BUSINESS PLANNING

CLICK HERE OR CALL US AT 909-307-6282 TO SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION.