The Kovel Letter: Extending Attorney-Client Privilege to Accountants
In complex legal matters, particularly those involving tax law or trust administration, maintaining the confidentiality of communications between clients, attorneys, and accountants is crucial. This is where the Kovel Letter comes into play. Named after the 1961 case U.S. v. Kovel, this tool extends attorney-client privilege to accountants working under the direction of an attorney, ensuring that sensitive communications remain protected.
What is a Kovel Letter?
A Kovel Letter is a formal agreement where an attorney hires an accountant or tax professional to assist in providing legal advice. Under this setup, communications between the client, the accountant, and the attorney are treated as if they were coming directly from the attorney, thus extending the protections of attorney-client privilege to those interactions. The case of U.S. v. Kovel set the precedent for this, where the court ruled that the accountant’s communications could be protected under certain conditions.
The key to this protection lies in the fact that the accountant must be assisting the attorney in delivering legal advice. This simple but effective arrangement creates a powerful shield, allowing clients to discuss complex financial matters with their legal team in full confidence that their communications will not be exposed.
Attorney-Client Privilege and the Role of the Kovel Letter
Attorney-client privilege is a fundamental principle of the legal system that allows for confidential communications between a lawyer and their client. This privilege is essential for ensuring that clients feel safe disclosing all relevant details to their legal team, which in turn helps lawyers provide effective representation.
The Kovel Letter extends this privilege to non-lawyers, including secretaries, clerks, and crucially, accountants. The rationale behind this is clear: attorneys often need the help of accountants to properly understand a client’s financial situation, especially when providing legal advice in cases involving tax or trust administration.
Why Not Just Use Account-Client Privilege?
Although federal law, specifically Section 7525 of the Internal Revenue Code, provides some limited protection for accountant-client communications, it is much more restricted than attorney-client privilege. For instance, the accountant-client privilege does not apply in criminal tax matters or to other investigations beyond the IRS.
This is why the Kovel Letter becomes indispensable. It allows attorneys and their clients to bridge the gap between legal advice and financial expertise, providing a comprehensive shield that can be vital in situations where the stakes are high.
Learn more: Do Living Trusts File a Tax Return?
How Does the Kovel Letter Work in Practice?
To ensure that the Kovel Letter effectively protects communications, a few conditions must be met:
Engagement by the Attorney: The accountant must be hired directly by the attorney, not the client. A written engagement letter should outline the accountant’s role in assisting with legal advice.
Confidentiality: Communications between the attorney, accountant, and client must remain confidential and directly related to the provision of legal services. Reports from the accountant should be marked as “confidential” and directed to the attorney, not the client.
Invoicing: The accountant should invoice the attorney directly. If the client is billed, it can undermine the privilege by implying that the accountant is working for the client rather than the attorney.
Scope of Service: The accountant’s services must be related to legal advice, not traditional accounting or tax preparation.
Risks and Pitfalls of the Kovel Letter
While the Kovel Letter is a powerful tool, it is not without risks. If the letter is poorly drafted or improperly managed, it could fail to protect the intended communications:
Scope of Services: The accountant’s work must be strictly related to legal advice. If the services are purely accounting-related, such as tax preparation, the privilege may not apply.
Disclosure: Any accidental disclosure of privileged information, such as through insecure communication channels, can break the privilege.
Invoicing Issues: If the accountant invoices the client directly, the privilege could be lost, as it suggests the accountant is not working for the attorney.
When is a Kovel Letter Useful?
The Kovel Letter is especially useful in situations involving potential IRS investigations or litigation. It is common in tax law when there is a risk that a civil tax matter could escalate into a criminal investigation. In such cases, structuring the engagement with an accountant through a Kovel Letter can ensure that communications remain protected.
Similarly, in trust administration, where litigation between trustees and beneficiaries is likely, a Kovel Letter can protect sensitive financial communications. Trustees often rely on accountants and other experts to handle complex financial matters, and having these communications fall under attorney-client privilege can be a critical safeguard.
Learn more: What Taxes Do Trust & Probate Beneficiaries Pay?
The Kovel Letter is an indispensable tool for extending attorney-client privilege to accountants and other experts who assist in legal matters. By carefully structuring these relationships and adhering to the conditions that maintain privilege, clients can ensure that their communications remain confidential and protected. Whether dealing with complex tax issues, trust administration, or litigation, the Kovel Letter can be a critical part of a robust legal strategy.
Learn more: Shelter your Money for Your Family Tax & Creditor Free!
BETHEL LAW CORPORATION
ESTATE PLANNING | ELDER LAW | BUSINESS PLANNING
CLICK HERE OR CALL US AT 909-307-6282 TO SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION.
